Saturday, September 30, 2017

Social Media Notes # 2: The Alienation of Diaspora Jewry

Michael Lumish

{Also published at the Elder of Ziyon and Jews Down Under.}

In a Facebook post, our friend Susan George references a Ha'aretz article by Yehuda Bauer, professor emeritus at the Avraham Harman Institute of Contemporary Jewry at Hebrew University, entitled, The Danger of Alienating Diaspora Jews.

As a non-Jewish supporter of both Israel and the Jewish people, George is curious about pro-Israel Jewish thoughts on the article.

I will toss in my two cents.

The first thing that I noticed, of course, is that the opinion piece is published in Ha'aretz which immediately sets off "alarm bells" for the simple reason that Ha'aretz is an anti-Israel newspaper.

Ha'aretz would not even support the Israeli baseball team - the Mensches on the Benches - because it had too many Americans.

They publish Gideon Levy and Amira Hass.

Hass believes that Arabs have a moral right to throw stones at Jewish children and both are despicable from anything that resembles a pro-Israel / pro-Jewish perspective.

Referring to American Jewry - and this is the article's primary thesis - Yehuda Bauer writes:
Without their support, the State of Israel would not have been established, and it cannot exist without such support today either.
Both claims are false.

The State of Israel was built by Jews and many Arabs who in the decades prior to 1948 created the infrastructure - physical, transportational, military, agricultural, industrial, and political - for the establishment of the country.

The role of American Jewry was significant, economic, but adjacent.

It was not central.

Israel most certainly can exist despite decreasing American Jewish friendship, although it would obviously be more difficult. Thankfully, Israel also has tremendous support among large swaths of self-identified American Christians who have far more political influence in the United States than does the American Jewish community.

Furthermore, American Jewry is not abandoning Israel.

According to a 2013 Pew Research Poll:
emotional attachment to Israel has not waned discernibly among American Jews in the past decade, though it is markedly stronger among Jews by religion (and older Jews in general) than among Jews of no religion (and younger Jews in general).
The enemies of Israel, and of the Jewish people, would like to divide and conquer, but this is not going to happen anytime soon.

Jewish Democratic Party Obama supporters are not abandoning Israel. Instead, they will kvetch. They will bitch and moan and whine and complain but at the end of the day, they will stick with their family.

{Bets, anyone?}

But the fact of the matter is that Israel has more economic, scholarly, scientific and diplomatic connections throughout the world today than it ever has in its history.

While the Jewish people in the Middle East remain under considerable threat by the much larger Arab-Muslim population surrounding it, it is also considerably stronger than at any previous point.

Bauer suggests that most American Jews care about internal Israeli religious squabbles.

He writes:
The Israeli government’s policy toward non-Orthodox streams of Jewry, which represent 90 percent of American Jews, threatens the connection that American Jews have to Israel, and is liable to weaken that link to such an extent that it results in apathy and a refusal to act on Israel’s behalf even during a crisis. Simply put, the policy of the current Israeli government is endangering Israel’s existence.
This is also false.

According to a January 24, 2017 article entitled, American and Israeli Jews: Twin Portraits From Pew Research Center Surveys, only fourteen percent of Israeli Jews and eighteen percent of U.S. Jews consider "social, religious, or political problems" to be central.

Most American Jews have very little interest in the arcane doings of Israel's religious policies toward "non-Orthodox streams of Jewry."

Most of us simply do not care.

Although we generally support Israel we honestly tend not to fret over Israel's Jew v. Jew religious disputations. Speaking strictly for myself, I find them vaguely annoying, but little beyond that and I am someone who follows Israel on a daily basis. As a lightly religious Jew I do not much care and my bet is that my lightly religious fellow American Jews do not much care, either.

Thus what I conclude from Professor Bauer's article is that it represents a growing tendency for western political divisiveness, more generally.

The current American spirit of emotive chaos that came into place in the months prior to Donald Trump's fantastical defeat of Hillary Clinton is causing far greater ruptures in American society than anyone expected.

In the United States, people are at one another's throats.

Families are rendered.

Friendships are broken.

And there is violence in the streets from Charlottesville to Berkeley.

But the truth is that most American Jews remain supportive of Israel and most do not worry about Jewish interreligious squabbles within that country.

You can be reasonably sure that going forward - despite Jewish pearl clutching - American Jewry will, at least within our lifetimes, continue to strongly support Israel.


  1. Diaspora Jews who hate Israel fear that they will have their self appointed legitimacy cut out from under them. My view is that Diaspora Jews who hate Israel don't matter. And the so called relationship between Israel and the US has less and less importance every day.

    1. Yup. Israel does not need the United States as much as many people like to think.

      Israel's relationship with the US and American Jewry is important, but the country is more-and-more looking East, not West.

  2. Diaspora Jews are becoming alienated from Israel because they long-ago completely-abandoned belief in Torah and practicing its teachings.

    Jews who actually believe in Torah and dedicate their lives to practicing its teachings are NOT becoming alienated from Israel. For example:

    “Orthodox Jews make aliyah in far greater numbers than those of other denominations.”

    SOURCE: Article by Amy Spiro, 2008 July 4, The Jewish Week, page 12
    Why Israel’s 1967 Borders are Undefendable:
    How intermarriage harms
    Jewish sovereignty over the Land of Israel
    How Shabbat-desecration harms
    Jewish sovereignty over Jerusalem:
    How Torah Can Defeat Terrorism
    (based on the teachings of Rabbi Nachman of Breslov ZYA)

  3. OT but still important:

  4. From the this will not end well dep't:

    CBS Legal Exec: No Sympathy For Vegas ‘Because Country Music Fans Often Are Republican’

    1. Well, ya know, it's because they're all the same. That might sound a bit bigoted, but remember that country music fans aren't high on the intersectionality pyramid so I'm on solid ground and well within my safe space. But, ya know, a lot of those folks used to vote for the Democrats and fairly recently at that. Jimmy Carter swept the country music vote, and so did Bill Clinton. So, what changed? Who changed? and why?

  5. Here's another link concerning what shouldn't be, but has become a political football to advance the Arab narrative and entitlement to Palestine.

    An old acquaintance in Berkeley once told me that I was "really a Khazarian." I told him he was really an asshole.

  6. Another major reason for the alienation of Diaspora Jewry [which is rarely mentioned] is the insanely-high rate-of-intermarriage between Diaspora Jewry and non-Jews. Children of intermarriage, even those who are categorized as Jews, are less likely to be pro-Israel than those with 100% Jewish ancestors.
    Dishonest Reporting: Media Bias against Israel
    Can Jews learn something from Captain Kirk?
    New York Times Erases Israel from Map:
    How to Convict the New York Times
    of Unfair Bias Against Israel:
    Buying or reading anti-Israel, anti-Jewish, anti-Judaism newspapers, like The New York Times, is worse than reading pornography. I never get tired of attacking The New York Times because The New York Times never gets tired of attacking the Jewish State and the Jewish People and the Jewish Faith.

  7. And just in case any acquaintance says otherwise: