A Word with the University of California

Michael Lumish

{The following is from Tammi Benjamin of the ACHMA Initiative. - ML}

Dear Friends,

This morning, the following letter was sent from 47 organizations and 176 faculty members to University of California President Janet Napolitano, urging her to ensure that UC faculty are not permitted to use the classroom as a pulpit for anti-Semitic and anti-Zionist political advocacy and activism.

Best regards,

Tammi

Begin forwarded message:

Subject: Serious concerns about political advocacy and activism in classrooms in violation of UC policies

Date: November 1, 2016 at 7:14:22 AM PDT

To: President <president@ucop.edu>

Cc: regentsoffice@ucop.edu, chancellor@berkeley.edu, chancellor@ucdavis.edu, chancellor@uci.edu, chancellor@ucla.edu, chancellor@ucmerced.edu, chancellor@ucr.edu, henry.yang@ucsb.edu, chancellor@ucsd.edu, Chancellor@ucsf.edu, chancellor@ucsc.edu, eddie.island@ucop.edu, Aimee.Dorr@ucop.edu, chesse@berkeley.edu, Robert.Powell@ucop.edu, senator.liu@senate.ca.gov, assemblymember.medina@assembly.ca.gov, assemblymember.weber@assembly.ca.gov, senator.block@senate.ca.gov

President Janet Napolitano

Office of the President, 

University of California

1111 Franklin St., 12^th Floor

Oakland, CA  94607

Dear President Napolitano,

We are 47 religious, civil rights, education and research organizations, as well as 176 individual faculty members on campuses across the country.  Many of our members are part of the UC community, including UC alumni.  We write to express our grave concern at what we believe to be the improper behavior of anti-Zionist faculty and student instructors, who use the classroom as a pulpit for political advocacy and activism in violation of UC policies and conventional academic ethics designed to curb exactly such abuse. 

An examination into the vetting process for the student-taught course “Palestine: A Settler-Colonial Analysis,” at UC-Berkeley, revealed that the Regents Policy on Course Content was either ignored or breached by the course’s sponsoring department, Ethnic Studies.  Even after Dean Carla Hesse asked Ethnic Studies to re-review the syllabus in light of the Regents Policy, the department chair approved the course, denying that it had any particular political agenda or that it crossed the line from education to indoctrination.  We find it hard to believe that a course with an obviously one-sided anti-Israel reading list, exclusively anti-Israel guest speakers, and a clear intent to justify the elimination of the State of Israel is considered to be consistent with Regents Policy.  

This course at UC-Berkeley is not an isolated case.  In a similar case a year ago, an almost identical course at UC Riverside, “Palestine & Israel: Settler-Colonialism and Apartheid,” was proposed by a student instructor under the supervision of an openly anti-Zionist faculty advisor in the English Department. When confronted with similar concerns about an inadequate vetting process that did not ensure the course’s compliance with the Regents Policy on Course Content before its approval, UCR officials there, too, claimed after the fact that the unambiguously one-sided, proselytizing course was in compliance with all UC policies. In stark contrast, Verity Educate, a non-partisan, non-profit group that analyzes the educational accuracy and objectivity of classroom curricula, determined that the UCR course “reflects a singular interpretation” and cautioned that the purposeful lack of political balance will result in students “com[ing] to see one argument as the mainstream or accepted view.”

We are deeply troubled that courses like these receive approval, despite the fact that they are blatantly politically-motivated and intended to indoctrinate students and are thus in violation of the Regents Policy on Course Content. We suggest that the faculty members responsible for overseeing course content, particularly at the departmental level, are failing to exercise due diligence in reviewing and approving courses either because they share the anti-Zionist political perspective of the proselytizing instructors and faculty and condone the promotion of that perspective in the classroom, or because they hope to avoid the controversy that rejecting the courses could initiate. 

On at least four UC campuses, entire departments are dominated by faculty who have publicly endorsed a boycott of Israeli universities and scholars, and several department chairs and program directors have publicly endorsed an academic boycott of Israel.  These departments have misused academic programming on their campuses to promote the political program of BDS.

We firmly believe in and strongly support the protections provided by the Constitution’s First Amendment for extramural expression by all university faculty members, even their right to express opinions and support causes that we find morally reprehensible or even antisemitic.  We object, however, when faculty members use their university positions and taxpayer resources to recruit for an antisemitic political movement, indoctrinate their students to support the elimination of the Jewish state, or allow their colleagues to do so.  As the UC-wide Committee on Academic Freedom has made abundantly clear, professors “who abuse their position to indoctrinate students cannot claim the protection of academic freedom.”

The effects of this abuse extend beyond corruption of the academic mission. Recent studies show that anti-Zionist expression, particularly the promotion of BDS, whether found on the campus quad or in the lecture hall, is strongly correlated with acts of anti-Jewish hostility, including assault, harassment, discrimination, suppression of speech, and displays of antisemitic graffiti and flyers (such as those seen recently at UC- Berkeley).  Tellingly, these studies also show a very strong correlation between faculty who have endorsed an academic boycott of Israel and acts of anti-Jewish hostility.  Schools with one or more faculty boycotters are four times more likely to be the scene of incidents targeting Jewish students for harm.

In 2014, your office issued two statements reaffirming that faculty and student instructors are bound by the Regents Policy on Course Content.  However, as evidenced by the recent examples at UC-Berkeley and UC-Riverside, it is clear that the Regents Policy is being disregarded on UC campuses.  And, with the notable exception of Dean Carla Hesse at UC-Berkeley, it seems that UC administrators are not reminding faculty of the vital importance of safeguarding academic freedom from abuse and of the faculty’s obligation to be diligent in enforcing the Regents policy.

Therefore, we urge you to take the following steps:

1. Issue a statement that describes and re-asserts the Regents Policy on Course Content and the UC Policy on Academic Freedom (APM 010), and that clarifies that the “advance of personal interest” and “political indoctrination” constitutes serious misuse of the classroom.

2. Charge each of the UC Chancellors with urging their respective academic senates to ensure that all courses are explicitly and carefully evaluated for their compliance with the standards of academic propriety as spelled out in the Regents Policy on Course Content.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. We look forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely,

Organizations:

Academic Council for Israel

Accuracy in Academia

Aggies for Israel 

Alpha Epsilon Pi Fraternity (AEPi)

Alums for Campus Fairness

AMCHA Initiative

AMCHA UCLA Alumni

American Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists

American Institute for Jewish Research

Americans for Peace and Tolerance

American Truth Project 

BEAR: Bias Education, Advocacy & Resources

Chabad Jewish Student Group at UC Berkeley

Club Z

Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America (CAMERA)

Davis Faculty for Israel

Eagles Wings

Endowment for Middle East Truth (EMET)

Fuel For Truth

Hasbara Fellowships

Institute for Black Solidarity with Israel

Iranian American Jewish Federation

Israeli-American Council (IAC)

Israel Peace Initiative (IPI)

JAM - Jewish Awareness Movement

Jerusalem U

Jews Indigenous to the Middle East and North Africa (JIMENA)

Middle East Forum

National Conference on Jewish Affairs

National Council of Young Israel

NCSY

Middle East Political and Information Network (MEPIN)

Proclaiming Justice to the Nations   

Roc4Israel

Scholars for Peace in the Middle East

Simon Wiesenthal Center   

StandWithUs   

Stop BDS on Campus

Students and Parents Against Campus Anti-Semitism

Students Supporting Israel 

Students Supporting Israel at UC Irvine

Students Supporting Israel at UCLA

Students Supporting Israel at UC Santa Barbara

The Israel Christian Nexus

The Israel Group

The Shofar Project

Zionist Organization of America

Faculty:

* indicates faculty at a University of California campus

* Alex Groisman, UC San Diego, Associate Professor of Physics 

Alexander Kogan, Rutgers University, Professor 

* Alexander Shukolyukov PhD, UC San Diego, Project Scientist 

* Alexei A. Maradudin, UC Irvine, Research Professor 

* Alvin Sokolow, UC Davis, Emeritus 

Amalia Kessler, Stanford University, Professor 

* Amina Harris, UC Davis, Director, Honey and Pollination Center 

* Ana Kasirer-Friede, UC San Diego, Project Scientist 

Andrea Greenbaum, Barry University, Professor 

* Andrew Lowy, UC San Diego, Professor 

* Andrew Viterbi, UC San Diego Dept. of Electrical & Computer Engineering, Professor Emeritus 

* Arnold Felsenfeld MD, UC Los Angeles, Professor of Medicine Emeritus 

* Avi Yagil, UC San Diego, Professor 

* Barbara Weiser MD, UC Davis School of Medicine, Professor Emeritus 

Barry R. Chiswick, George Washington University, Professor 

* Barry Weissman, UC Los Angeles, Professor Emeritus 

* Benjamin Grinstein, UC San Diego, Distinguished Professor and Departmental Chair 

* Boaz Arzi, UC Davis, Associate Professor 

* Brian Kaye, UC San Francisco, Clinical Professor of Medicine 

* Brian Keating, UC San Diego, Professor 

Bruce A Phillips, University of Southern California & Hebrew Union College, Professor 

Bruno Chaouat, University of Minnesota, Professor 

Carmel Chiswick, George Washington University, Research Professor 

* Daniel Arovas, UC San Diego, Professor of Physics 

* Daniel Cole, UC Los Angeles, Associate Professor 

* Daniel J.B. Mitchell, UC Los Angeles, Professor Emeritus 

* Daniel Neuhauser, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

Daniel Palanker, Stanford University, Professor 

* Daniel Selden, UC Santa Cruz, Professor 

Daphne Desser, University of Hawaii at Manoa, Professor 

* David Bensimon, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

* David C. Rapoport, UC Los Angeles, Professor Emeritus 

* David Feifel, UC San Diego, Professor 

* David Goodblatt, UC San Diego, Professor 

* David H. Gershuni, UC San Diego, Professor Emeritus 

* David Kleinfeld, UC San Diego, Distinguished Professor 

* David Kliger, UC Santa Cruz, Professor Emeritus 

David Orzech PhD, San Francisco State University, Professor Emeritus 

David Patterson, University of Texas at Dallas, Professor 

* David Savar MD FACS, UC Los Angeles, Associate Professor 

* Dennis Carson, UC San Diego, Professor 

Dennis Rutledge, George Mason University, Professor 

Dr. Bernice Stone, California State University, Fresno, Professor 

* Dr. Ivan Schuller, UC San Diego, Distinguished Professor 

Dr. Jonathan Roth, San Jose State University, Professor 

Dr. Robert O. Freedman, Johns Hopkins University, Visiting Professor 

* Edward Rabin, UC Davis, School of Law, Professor of Law Emeritus 

* Edwin M. Epstein, UC Berkeley, Professor Emeritus 

* Ehud Greenspan, UC Berkeley, Professor of the Graduate School 

* Eli Yablonovitch, UC Berkeley, Professor 

* Elijah Polak, UC Berkeley, Professor Emeritus 

Ellen Cannon, Northeastern Illinois University, Professor of Political Science and Public Administration 

Elliott Bloom, Stanford University, Professor Emeritus 

* Eric Gans, UC Los Angeles, Distinguished Professor Emeritus 

* Ethan Miller, UC Santa Cruz, Professor & Veritas Presidential Chair in Storage 

* Eyal Raz, UC San Diego, Professor of Medicine 

* Flor Feldman, UC Berkeley Extension, Mathematics Instructor 

Franck Salameh, Boston College, Associate Professor of Near Eastern Studies 

* Fred Milstein, UC Santa Barbara, Professor Emeritus 

* Gabe Vorobiof MD FACC FASE, UC Los Angeles, David Geffen School of Medicine, Associate Professor 

Gabriel Brahm, Northern Michigan University, Associate Professor 

* Gary Fouse, UC Irvine Department of Continuing Ed, Adjunct Lecturer 

* Guershon Harel, UC San Diego, Professor 

H. C. Tenenbaum DDS Dip. Perio. PhD FRCD(C), University of Toronto, Tel Aviv University, Professor 

* Harold Burger, UC Davis, Professor of Medicine Emeritus 

* Harry Pellman MD, UC Irvine, Clinical Professor of Pediatrics 

* Harry Rubin, UC Berkeley, Professor 

* Howard Taras, UC San Diego, Professor 

* Ilan Benjamin, UC Santa Cruz, Professor 

* Ilan Roth, UC Berkeley, Retired 

* Ira Monosson, UC Los Angeles and University of Southern California, Asst Clinical Professor, Emeritus 

Irving Biederman, University of Southern California, Professor 

Itzhak Bars, University of Southern California, Professor 

J. Edward Wright, University of Arizona, Professor 

* Jack F. Kirsch, UC Berkeley, Professor of the Graduate school 

* Jascha Kessler, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

* Jason Sicklick, UC San Diego School of Medicine, Associate Professor 

Jay D. Amsterdam MD, University of Pennsylvania, Professor Emeritus 

* Jay Rosenheim, UC Davis, Professor 

Jeffrey D. Ullman, Stanford University, Professor of Computer Science Emeritus 

Jeffrey Herf, University of Maryland, College Park, Distinguished University Professor 

* Jeffrey Jacobs, UC Los Angeles, Director of Psychological Services 

Jeffrey Koseff, Stanford University, Professor 

John Riskind, George Mason University, Professor 

John Rothmann, University of San Francisco, Fromm Institute, Professor 

* Jon Schuller, UC Santa Barbara, Professor 

* Joseph L. Witztum MD, UC San Diego, Distinguished Professor of Medicine 

* Joshua Feder MD, UC San Diego, Associate Clinical Professor 

* Judea Pearl, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

* Karen L. Fox-Asraf, UC Irvine Extension, Academic Appointee, Retired 

Karen Petersen, Middle Tennessee State University, Interim Dean of Liberal Arts & Professor 

Kent Harber, Rutgers University at Newark, Professor 

* Larry Yelowitz, UC Irvine, Professor Emeritus 

* Leeka Kheifets, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

* Leila Beckwith, UC Los Angeles, Professor Emeritus 

Leonard Saxe, Brandeis University, Professor 

Linda Zwang-Weissman, Santa Monica College, Adjunct Professor 

* Louis Bouchard, UC Los Angeles, Associate Professor 

Louis Steinberg, Rutgers University, Associate Professor 

* Marc Lerner, UC Irvine, Clinical Professor 

* Marci Reiss, UC San Diego, Lecturer, Staff 

Mark Levine, University of Denver, Professor 

* Marvin Alkin, UC Los Angeles, Professor Emeritus / Research Professor 

* Melvin Scheinman, UC San Francisco, Professor 

Mervin F. Verbit, Touro College and University System, Professor 

* Michael J Saxton, UC Davis, Research Chemist Emeritus 

* Michael Kaback MD, UC San Diego School of Medicine, Professor Pediatrics & Reproductive Medicine 

* Michael Pollak, UC Riverside, Professor Emeritus 

Michael Rockland, Rutgers University, Professor of American Studies 

Michael Schuffler, University of Washington, Professor Emeritus 

Miriam Bailin, Washington University in St. Louis, Professor of English 

Miriam Elman, Syracuse University, Associate Professor 

Mohammed Al-Azdee, University of Bridgeport (UB), Associate Professor, Chair Mass Communication 

Monica Osborne, Pepperdine University, Visiting Assistant Professor 

* Morton Denn, UC Berkeley, Professor of Chemical Engineering Emeritus 

* Neil Levine MD, UC San Diego, Professor 

Nina Sabghir, York College, Assistant Professor 

Nir Yakoby, Rutgers University, Associate Professor 

* Nora Laiken PhD, UC San Diego School of Medicine, Lecturer, Asst. Dean Educational Support Services 

* Norma Landau, UC Davis, Professor Emerita 

Ofer Ben-Amots, Colorado College, Professor and Department Chair 

P. Darin Payne, University of Hawaii, Associate Professor 

* Pamela Cosman, UC San Diego, Professor, Associate Dean for Students 

* Paul J. Feldstein, UC Irvine, Professor of Health Care Management and Policy, Emeritus 

Peter Golden, Rutgers University, Professor Emeritus 

Philip Carl Salzman, McGill University, Professor of Anthropology 

* Philip Lubin, UC Santa Barbara, Professor of Physics 

R. Amy Elman, Kalamazoo College, Professor 

* Ralph Brindis MD MPH, UC San Francisco, Clinical Professor of Medicine 

* Ralph Lachman MD, UC Los Angeles and Stanford University, Professor Emeritus/Clinical Professor 

Ralph Rabkin, Stanford University, Professor of Medicine Emeritus 

* Raphael Zidovetzki, UC Riverside, Professor  

* Raya Feldman, UC Santa Barbara, Associate Professor 

* Richard Kaner, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

Robert B. Levy, University of Miami, Professor 

Robert Friedmann, Georgia State University, Professor Emeritus 

* Robert H. Cole, UC Berkeley, Professor of Law Emeritus 

Robert Levine, Ohio State University, Professor of Linguistics 

Robert Phillips, Ball State University, Professor 

* Robert Winer, UC Irvine College of Medicine, Adjunct Professor of Medicine, Retired 

* Robert Zeiger, UC San Diego, Clinical Professor Pediatrics 

* Robin Morris, UC Santa Cruz, Associate Adjunct Professor 

Ronald Mehler, California State University, Northridge, Professor 

* Russ Kino, UC Los Angeles, Assistant Professor Medicine 

* Ruth Covell, UC San Diego, Clinical Professor 

Ruth Weisberg, University of Southern California, Professor 

Samuel Edelman, University of Miami, Miller Center Fellow and Adjunct Professor 

Sandor Reichman, California State University, Northridge, Professor of Chemistry Emeritus 

Sara Reguer, Brooklyn College, Professor/Chair 

* Sarale Cohen, UC Los Angeles, Professor Emeritus 

* Sheldon Rothblatt, UC Berkeley, Professor Emeritus 

* Sheldon Wolf, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

* Shimon Weiss, UC Los Angeles, Distinguished Professor 

* Sonia Ancoli-Israel, UC San Diego, Professor Emeritus 

Spencer Pack, Connecticut College, Professor of Economics 

* Stanley Brandes, UC Berkeley, Professor 

Stanley Dubinsky, University of South Carolina, Professor of Linguistics 

Stanley Messer, Rutgers University, Distinguished Professor 

* Stephen C. Bondy, UC Irvine, Professor 

* Stephen White, UC Davis, Professor 

* Steven P. Segal, UC Berkeley, School of Social Welfare, Professor of the Graduate Division 

* Steven Schwartz, UC Los Angeles, Assistant Professor 

* Steven Tadelis, UC Berkeley, Professor 

* Steven Weinbaum, UC Davis, Professor Emeritus 

* Stuart Schweitzer, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

Susan Trencher, George Mason University, Professor 

* Svetlana Jitomirskaya, UC Irvine, Professor 

* Tammi Rossman-Benjamin, UC Santa Cruz, Lecturer 

* Vladimir Mandelshtam, UC Irvine, Professor 

Wendy Mulcahy, CSU Chico, Faculty 

* William Newman, UC Los Angeles, Professor 

* William Schwartz MD, UC San Francisco, Clinical Professor of Medicine, Retired 

Yakov Eliashberg, Stanford University, Professor 

* Yehuda Bock, UC San Diego, Distinguished Researcher 

* Yitzhak Tor, UC San Diego, Professor 

* Zev bar-Lev, San Diego State University, Professor Emeritus 

Cc:   UC Regents

        UC Chancellors

        Regent Eddie Island, Chair Academic and Student Affairs Committee UC Board of Regents

        Aimee Dorr, UC Provost and Executive Vice President

        Carla Hesse, Executive Dean of the College of Letters and Science 

        Robert L. Powell, Chair Academic Senate UC Berkeley

        Senator Carol Liu, Chair California Senate Standing Committee on Education

        Assembly Member Jose Medina, Chair California Assembly Higher Education Committee       

        Assembly Member Shirley Weber, Chair Assembly Select Committee on Campus Climate

        Senator Marty Block, Chair California Legislative Jewish Caucus