Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Exposure of Political Hypocrisy from Down Under

by oldschooltwentysix 

(cross posted at oldschooltwentysix)

I don't know Daphne Anson, but some of her personal story parallels my own, as to the evolution of thinking we both share about the situation of irrational hatred for Israel and its manifestations, including those from many on the Left that act as if the sole judges of morality.

This "progressive antisemitism" presently combines with Muslim antisemitism to bring forth almost all the incitement to hatred against Israel and Jews that we see and hear on an everyday basis. Most people reject these extremist views and can recognize the difference between valid criticism of Israel and hatred for it as the Jewish state.

Yet, the question arises whether the disparate treatment of Israel, as compared to ANY other state, is itself discriminatory and convincing evidence of antisemitism.

Which brings me DA's post about words reported from a member of the Australian Parliament who rose in support of a motion on the subject of human rights in Iran, Kelly O’Dwyer. Her full statement can be found at J-Wire in an article entitled: "The Silence of the Greens."

I think that MP O'Dwyer raises some good points, especially concerning the Greens, and it makes me ask why should people follow advice from others who raise theories that in practice seem to fly in the face of experience and reality?

She assuredly understands the issue of human rights and the context:
There must be no more serious and heinous act in this world than a government turning on its own people and committing violent atrocities on its own citizenry.

President of Iran, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, is her main target and she sets forth a small litany of his hate speech, including that Israel should be annihilated.
Any one of these statements on its own warrants immediate condemnation, yet this despicable vitriol is left unchallenged and has been left unchallenged too often and for too long.

She then speaks about Australia, but it has wider ramifications to us all who care about the use and abuse of human rights internationally:
In Australia during this time one must ask the questions- Who stands conspicuously quiet? Who stands silent while these human rights are abused? It is not those sitting directly opposite me. It is, in fact, the Greens, those people who suggest that they are the champions of human rights and the keepers of the moral chalice, those professed keepers of all that is right and ethical. Where, I ask you, is Senator Brown in condemning these actions? Where is Senator Hanson-Young on her soapbox demanding justice? Where is the member for Melbourne, Adam Bandt, in this chamber supporting this motion? Where are the Greens protests in the streets? Most importantly, given all that we have learned about the boycott, divestments and sanctions scheme that grew from the Greens local council movement in Marrickville, where are the calls for the boycotts of Iranian companies or even of Syrian ones, to be truly consistent? No, all that is simply reserved for Israel.

Interestingly, the Greens also profess to be strong champions of human rights, particularly for those who are homosexual. Yet it is the country of Israel, the only democracy in the region, that legislates rights for women and homosexuals. In fact, in a recent poll conducted by GayCities.com in conjunction with American Airlines, Tel Aviv was rated the best gay travel destination of 2011. Yet here the Greens condemn Israel and not Iran.
Could you imagine if the Prime Minister of Israel had prayed for the ‘annihilation’ of the Palestinians? How many motions would the Greens have moved by now? How many press releases, demonstrations and media conferences would they have called? I conducted a search on the Greens website. I typed ‘Iran’ into their search feature, 23 results were returned and in those results there was not one mention—not one, single, solitary mention—of the atrocities that have taken place, of the abhorrent preachings of the President of Iran or of the blatant human rights abuses posed against ethnic minorities, women and homosexuals. However, if you type in ‘Israel’ you will find pages and pages and pages—in particular pages as to how you can be involved as well in the BDS movement. This is a truly sad state of affairs and it is of great concern in particular to me that the Greens do not stand with us in this chamber against such violence against human rights workers, women’s rights activists, journalists and government opponents.
The Greens seem to quote the UN when it suits them and ignore them when it does not conform to their agenda. And make no mistake: the Greens agenda on Israel is well and truly on show.

She seems to describe a familiar group, at least to me, who are so convinced that they can only do good that they dismiss arguments to the contrary and ignore the daily events in Iran and elsewhere. To them it is so simple: Israel and pro-Israel supporters, as seen in the disproportionate lack of attention they give anywhere else. Should these advocates possess any more credibility in these matters than those they love to criticize? Or, all things considered, perhaps they should have much less.


  1. Good post, School.

    It actually dove-tails nicely with my conversation with Fizziks.

    It seems to me that we are dealing with a number of interrelated issues that all seem to come back to progressive-left malice toward Israel, if not toward the Jewish people, and their acquiescence toward radical Islam, whether from the Brotherhood or Hamas or the Iranian government.

    I was a Green Party member for awhile, actually.

    I certainly will not make that mistake, again. 

  2. Not that I would expect them to be able to hear or see, but it is time that they lose their place on the pedestal, kicking people who stand for universal human rights for ALL, not just victims of Islamophobia and Western oppression.

    In my opinion, they hurt human rights more than they help it.

  3. Consider yourself on the vanguard.

    You are well ahead of the curve.

  4. Such a pleasure to find another couple of blogs shining some candle light in a dark and filthy place. It really is.

    Consider yourself bookmarked.

  5. Welcome to Israel Thrives, geofff.

    Please feel free to participate at will.

  6. They are enemies of human rights. In truth they care nothing at all for the Palestinians. For them this is about something else entirely.

  7. What is it about, do you suppose?

    The power to bully other people?

    Because you are absolutely right, the progressive left as a movement does not stand for anything even remotely resembling universal human rights.

    Just ask the Darfurans.

  8. I missed this.

    What is it about? It's been a long time since I left the Australian version of the progressive left so maybe things have changed. 
    But from what I can remember it seemed to be mainly about their best chance of getting laid.

  9. Karam, here's another for your list of taboo topics around I-P in these venues.

    The forgotten refugees. The robbing and brutal expulsion of Jews from Arab lands (and Jerusalem and the West Bank) who had lived in these places for centuries before there were Muslims. 

  10. Ah, very good.

    While the whole world is well aware of Arab refugees, I would bet only a small percentage even knew that there were Jewish refugees.

    Thanks, geoffff